Large temporal variations of functional properties of outdoor equestrian arena surfaces and a new concept of evaluating reactivity with light weight deflectometer settlement curves

Sports physiological properties of ten sand or sand-mineral outdoor arenas, five with vertical drainage systems and five with an ebb and flow like system were assessed over a period of eight weeks. For each arena, the riding zone was spatially delineated, nine locations at medium to intensely used zones were selected by simple random sampling and used along the whole measurement period. A total of 72 values for the dynamic deflection modulus (Evd), attenuation (s/v), settlement (s) and moisture content (Vol %) were analyzed for each arena. A novel technique to analyze the settlement curves of the light weight deflectometer (LWD) to describe reactivity of the footing surface was introduced. Statistical testing was done by linear mixed models. Three of the five arenas with a vertical watering system were judged to be hard (Evd > 20 MN/m2), whereas all five arenas with an ebb and flow like watering systems were medium hard (Evd = 10-20 MN/m2) over the entire eight weeks. Significant (p<0.01) temporal differences in Evd, s/v and moisture were demonstrated for both watering systems; however, the spatial and temporal variations were much lower with the ebb-flow system. Temporal consistency in the parameters over the test weeks appeared to be a criterion for stability of the arena surface. The analysis of the settlement curves of the LWD showed that the slope symmetry has a large potential to describe the restoration of the energy of an equestrian surface than only the settlement, which requires further validation.